Thursday, May 24, 2018

Articles and Research Papers Discussing the Loyalty to India of Most Gujjar and Bakarwal Muslims of J&K

https://www.files.ethz.ch/isn/130468/SR106-EW01-GujjarPerspective.pdf

https://www.academia.edu/15278680/Tribal_Gujjars_of_Jammu_and_Kashmir

https://www.facebook.com/valleyonline.in/photos/a.723081364473062.1073741827.723067631141102/1233739503407243/?type=3&theater

https://www.reddit.com/r/india/comments/36938h/np_til_mohammad_din_gujjar_a_kashmiri_shepherd/

http://www.indiandefencereview.com/news/jk-muslim-gujjar-leader-backs-security-forces/

http://www.thehindu.com/todays-paper/tp-national/He-blew-the-whistle-on-the-Kargil-intruders/article16550850.ece

http://www.asianage.com/india/all-india/270418/kathua-put-the-spotlight-on-bakarwals-the-armys-eyes-and-ears-along-loc.html

https://scroll.in/article/876226/after-countrywide-outrage-against-its-support-for-kathua-accused-bjp-is-on-the-back-foot-in-jammu

Monday, April 30, 2018

Reports and Articles on Jihadist Terror Attacks in Jammu

http://www.thenorthlines.com/grenade-attack-at-jammu-bus-stand-3-injured/
http://www.tribuneindia.com/news/jammu-kashmir/sunjuwan-attack-5-soldiers-1-civilian-dead-3-terrorists-gunned-down/542221.html

http://www.satp.org/satporgtp/countries/india/states/jandk/data_sheets/majorincidents.htm

http://archives.digitaltoday.in/indiatoday/20060515/state-kashmir.html

http://www.tribuneindia.com/2001/20010805/main1.htm

http://www.frontline.in/static/html/fl1817/18170200.htm

http://www.thehindu.com/todays-paper/serial-terror-strikes-claim-35-lives-in-doda-and-udhampur/article3127483.ece

http://www.greaterkashmir.com/news/news/35-massacred-in-doda-udhampur/6099.html

https://www.outlookindia.com/website/story/means-and-ends/231179

http://www.tribuneindia.com/2005/20051011/main1.htm

Wednesday, April 25, 2018

Reports and Articles on the Terror Threat to India from Illegal Bangladeshi Migrants

http://indianexpress.com/article/india/papers-show-arrested-bangladeshis-helped-terror-operatives-pune-unit-5116780/ https://www.hindustantimes.com/kolkata/bengal-cops-seize-huge-quantity-of-explosives-bangladeshi-terror-link-suspected/story-wGzyomhncAE5KIX1TYBMeI.html https://www.hindustantimes.com/cities/jmb-s-nasirullah-responsible-for-burdwan-blast-held-in-bangladesh/story-lzfFKSfF9KiRyKG5VnM3kL.html

https://www.hindustantimes.com/india/burdwan-blast-arrested-woman-spills-the-beans-on-bangladesh-connection/story-Ko3Iv0NCPAvvECyO6arPaP.html

http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/other-states/burdwan-blast-accused-got-aadhaar-election-card/article7724249.ece

http://www.firstpost.com/india/six-top-jamaat-ul-mujahideen-bangladesh-activists-arrested-from-bengal-assam-3020768.html

https://www.ndtv.com/kolkata-news/information-from-arrested-jamaat-terrorists-to-be-shared-with-assam-kolkata-police-1468404

http://www.firstpost.com/india/seven-bangladeshi-jihadis-held-in-assam-29-arrests-in-state-so-far-2742318.html

http://www.claws.in/images/journals_doc/1399529456Mansi%20Mehrotra%20CJ%20Winter%202009.pdf

https://www.firstpost.com/politics/west-bengal-one-of-the-main-routes-of-terror-infiltration-says-bangladesh-is-mamata-banerjee-listening-3345506.html

https://idsa.in/idsacomments/potency-of-the-jmb-threat-to-india-security_agarwal-simon_030417

http://gnnliberia.com/2018/02/11/wanted-bangladeshi-terrorists-launched-new-terror-group-eastern-india-mha-issues-caution-notice/

http://www.firstpost.com/world/terror-threat-from-bangladesh-is-real-and-porous-borders-with-india-problematic-2873510.html https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/kolkata/Kolkata-identified-as-terror-hub/articleshow/22274766.cms

Friday, January 12, 2018

The Most Valid Way to Counter Islamism

Basically, four approaches are suggested to counter the menace of Islamism (right-wing political Islam, of which jihadist terrorism is the most extreme manifestation) – the first is anti-Muslim bigotry, which is actually counterproductive and only gives further fuel to the jihadist fire, the second is to harp on Muslim victimhood exaggerating it but without asking Muslims to introspect, which fails to explain why a harmless minority like the Yazidis of Iraq or a school-girl like Malala have been targets of jihadist terrorism, the third is denigrating Islam as a faith to make Muslims abandon Islam but which is only intellectually consistent coming from an atheist or agnostic for all faiths have controversial dimensions, and tu-tu-main-main debates over right or wrong interpretations of Islam or any other religion to prove superiority (otherwise, I do support promoting humanistic and progressive interpretations of Islam as accurate) can be endless, and the fourth one, which I subscribe to, is to promote a liberal and humanistic understanding of Muslim identity and Islam, rebutting wrong notions of perennial Muslim victimhood and portraying the likes of APJ Abdul Kalam as role models, which I think is the only viable option, and so, to acknowledge Kalam's Muslim-ness is essential if he is to be promoted as a role model for Muslims.


I do not believe that communalists under any banner, except arguably those actually resorting to killing innocent civilians, should be dehumanized or can never be logically made to modify their views, as the must-watch movie Road to Sangam, based on a true story, demonstrates, and to draw an analogy, you can see this video of a Muslim who initially wanted to become a terrorist wanting to blow up Jewish civilians but changed his standpoint about Israel for the better after visiting that country.

Thursday, December 21, 2017

Can India's Hindu Majority Be Entitled To Say It Has Grievances?

Our left-liberal friends never tire telling us about how the Indian Muslims joining the ranks of jihadist terror outfits are often victims of Hindu extremist violence, but can’t the same logic be applied the other way round too? Isn’t it possible that many of the Hindu extremists engaging in violence against innocent Muslims could have been victims of Muslim extremist violence by way of terrorist attacks or riots?

Violent Muslim extremism with the Indian Mujahidin, Indian Muslims joining the ISIS and Al Qaeda, vandalism in Malda, Muslim extremists killing Hindus in riots (including even the Gujarat riots of 2002, which weren't one-sided even after the Godhara train-burning), often instigated by hate speeches by leaders like Azam Khan and the Owaisi brothers, DOES EXIST in India (not only in Pakistan). The prospect of Hindu Majoritarianism taking an absolute fascist form to extinguish democracy some day or even taking us anywhere considerably close to that, as worrisome as it is for me, doesn't mean that if Muslim extremism can't dominate the country, the damage to Hindus' life and limb shouldn't still be a matter of as much concern for everyone, and communalism under one banner feeds communalism under the other; so, a genuine fight against communalism can never be selective.

I sincerely wish that a lot of left-liberals opposing negative stereotyping of Muslims (something I completely support) were equally careful to not make instances of Hindu extremism sound like "almost every average Hindu is out to get you, Muslims", such as by labelling our country as 'lynchistan' (when very many Muslims lead regular lives alongside Hindu friends, and Muslims from weak economic backgrounds have gone on to make it big in India, some examples including APJ Abdul Kalam, Irfan Khan, Nawazuddin Siddiqui, Irfan Pathan, Yusuf Pathan and several Indian Muslim entrepreneurs) or be okay with even lying about having been complete denial of justice for Muslim victims of hate crimes. Hundreds of Hindu extremists have rightly been convicted in the Gujarat riots for massacres in Ode, Sadarpura, Naroda Patiya, the Best Bakery, the Bilkis Bano gang-rape etc. at the behest of Hindu activists like the late Mukul Sinha (and not all Muslim extremists have been convicted; think Bitta Karate, killer of many Kashmiri Pandits, and Azam Khan, a venom-spewing politician allegedly involved in fanning riots from the Muslim side in Muzaffarnagar and Sahranpur), and many Muslims implicated in terror cases have even been acquitted... even in the case of beef lynchings, there have been several arrests, as you can see here, here, here and, here.

Yes, conscious, subconscious or unconscious bias in the form of a sense of bloated chauvinism based on birth-based identity and/or a general apathy towards extremism perpetuated against "others" by those of one's own community does exist among many Hindus, but the same is equally, if not more, true for very many (not all) Indian Muslims, who have an even higher section insisting on making scripture-based scientific claims without much basis, a propensity towards seeking to see themselves as perennial victims, having generalised hatred even for communities they have experienced no harm from (like Jews in the case of many Indian Muslims, or take the doctrinal intolerance towards Ahmedias) and believing in bizarre and baseless conspiracy theories that deny the very existence of jihadist terrorism, and if there are Hindus who don't sufficiently acknowledge secular Muslims, the vice versa is true as well, as many liberal Muslims concede, and to Hindu readers, I’d say that just because a lot of Muslims may not express their bigoted ideas to your face, it doesn’t mean that you must imagine that bigoted talk happens only among Hindus.


Besides, negative stereotyping of Hindus by Muslims is less understandable than the vice versa, for Muslims come in contact with Hindus more than Hindus do with Muslims (and secular Hindus are quite visible in the media, NGOs, judiciary, political class and academia), and given that owing to Muslims as an aggregate whole having failed to embrace wholeheartedly modern constitutional secular democracy (how many such Muslim-majority countries do we have? - yes, there are a few like Albania and Burkina Faso), sections of Muslims globally find themselves in conflict with those of other faiths (it's not just about Hindus in India), and therefore, it's for more and more Muslims to come out and prove their tolerance by being fully impartial in their outlook, for intolerance by others is largely (not entirely) only about antipathy to Muslims, there being hardly any very powerful, armed non-Muslim terror groups seeking to impose dictatorial theocratic rule. Indian Muslims would do better to (as many already do) embrace the approach of secular Indian nationalism of Maulana Azad (here is a piece by me clarifying misconceptions about him) Ashfaqullah Khan, APJ Abdul Kalam (who was a practising Muslim), and Muslims in our Indian defence forces, rather than imagine themselves as some marginalised monolith that needs to keep crying hoarse about some perennial victimhood (I have rebutted that line of thinking here) and sympathising with extremists from their community or believing in all kinds of bizarre and baseless conspiracy theories that deny the very existence of jihadist terrorism, and while wanting non-Muslims to care for Muslims' concerns, themselves overlooking the concerns of non-Muslims [except paying some lip service to the cause of those non-Muslims who fit into the "the enemy of my enemy is my friend" syndrome (like Christian victims of Hindu extremism, or victims of human rights violations in the northeast or Adivasi areas rather than only Muslim-majority Kashmir) or "I can use their victimhood to paint that community in a certain fashion" idea (like in the case of Dalits to promote Hinduphobia, just as many Hindu rightists cite issues like burqas and triple talaq not because they care for Muslim women but to portray Muslims as regressive people), but not caring for Hindu victims of riots and terrorism like the Kashmiri Pandits or Jat victims of Muzaffarnagar riots, over say, the Palestinians]. Fringe extremists among both Hindus (e.g. cow vigilantes) and Muslims (e.g. jihadist terrorists) have launched onslaughts, but no entire community has launched any onslaught on another. One ought to feel sad about Hindu riot victims in Muzaffarnagar, Assam, Gujarat and other places as much as Muslim riot victims, and the pain and suffering is the same, irrespective of which side the victim toll has been higher, and even feel sad for innocent Hindu shopkeepers beaten to pulp and consigned to wheel-chairs in places like Malda. Or for that matter, Hindu victims of Christian extremism in the northeast as you can see here, here, here, here, here, here, here, and here.

Laws that give state control only to Hindu temples and not places of worship of other religious groupings, the exemption of 25% quota for EWS kids only for minority schools, minority colleges misusing Articles 29 and 30 of the Indian constitution to give reservations to well-off minority kids but without fulfilling the constitutional mandate of making them study the minority culture, the lack of a large-scale secular outrage on the Supreme Court rejecting a petition to probe Kashmiri Pandits’ killings, Azam Khan not even being charge-sheeted or probed for his alleged role in fanning riots or his provocative speeches, the selective negative deconstruction of only Hindu theology and negative stereotyping of practising Hindus by left-liberals when practising Hindus are often progressive and humanistic with their own interpretations of faith etc. are relevant concerns that need to be addressed, and if someone wants to raise these without any hate for all Muslims or Christians, he/she deserves to be heard without being branded as a bigot, and you can't ideologically convert the Hindu extremists (I have actually managed to convert quite a few) if you just dismiss the idea that a majority community nationally can have grievances.

Thursday, November 16, 2017

Examples of Women Outperforming Men in Sports

Examples include Sarah Taylor and Kate Cross from England and Elysse Perry from Australia, who have interestingly made a mark in domestic men’s cricket. Sarah Taylor, an English wicketkeeper, had, at the age of 23 years, even been interestingly selected for the Sussex Men’s Second XI team to represent the English county, and she did play a men’s cricket match in Australia, even taking two catches. One of the most important developments in the area of women’s cricket in the recent times has been the story of Kate Cross, the fast bowler from England who became the first woman to have played in the Lancashire league in its 123-year history. There are other precedents to this as well. Arran Bridle had also played in the Lincolnshire Premier League in 2011. She played for Heywood and performed well in at least two matches. She took three wickets in one match and eight wickets in the other, against Clifton and Unsworth respectively. Elysse Perry is an Australian who has represented her country in both football and cricket and was the youngest adult cricketer for Australia (men included). She has also played in Sydney men’s grade cricket and took wickets of men in the same too.


An interesting piece of information with respect to domestic cricket in our country may be cited. In 2010, for the first time, the Baroda Cricket Association pitted its senior women’s team against under-14 boys’ teams in the under-14 DK Gaekwad Tournament and in the first match the girls played against the under-14 boys’ team of the Kiran More International Cricket Academy, the girls emerged victorious. In fact, they won three of the six matches they played in the tournament (the age difference should also, however, be taken into consideration, but would still be hard for male chauvinists to digest). An interesting fact is that in the first such match, the girls’ team comprised Taslim Sheikh, daughter of Mehendi Sheikh, coach of the famous male cricketers, the Pathan brothers – Irfan and Yusuf. And the captain of the girls’ team was Tarannum Pathan, another Pathan cricketer from Gujarat!

A prominent name historically that can be cited is that of American shooter Annie Oakley (1860-1926), who with her remarkable precision, thrilled spectators. At the age of fifteen, she outperformed famous marksman Francis Butler, who was ten years older to her and had laid a bet that he would perform better than her.


Danica Patrick from the United States of America was the first woman to win an Indy car-racing event and come 4th at a Las Vegas speedway event competing against men, Laleh Seddigh from Iran, a female Muslim female car racer has been a national champion competing against men, and is even known as the ‘Schumacher of the East’, and Alisha Abdullah from India has outperformed men in car-racing and bike-racing competitions.


In early 2015, a women-only crew won the Volvo Ocean race in Lorient defeating all the men’s teams! Female endurance athletes like Rory Bosio, Pam Reed and Lael Wilcox have beaten men in some of the toughest races in the world.



Tuesday, October 24, 2017

The Need for a Right to Education Act and a Strong Child Rights Commission in J&K

The importance of child rights commissions in the context of education can be gauged from an example from J&K, where the RTE Act doesn’t apply owing to Article 370 (the desirability of which is another debate altogether), and the local politicians there have only dilly-dallied over making a law giving effect to the idea that education in the age group of six to fourteen years is a fundamental right (fortunately, in 2014, however, we learnt of a bill to this effect being drafted in J&K), though Article 10 of the constitution of J&K gives J&Kites the same fundamental rights as other Indians. The incident relates to a school in the Poonch region denying admission to certain students, in which the students had to stage protests and finally, the school relented on pressure from the district authorities. However, had J&K had an institutionalized right to education in neighbourhood schools for a certain age group, their state child rights commission (which does exist), if given the requisite powers, could have taken charge. Those with access to education in Kashmir, have, in some cases, become technology entrepreneurs, scientists and public policy analysts, more of whom we need, as against more militants and stone-pelters who have played a major role in crippling the Kashmiri economy and earlier drove out most of the Hindu minority of the Kashmir valley. As Neelesh Misra and Rahul Pandita point out in their much acclaimed book The Absent State, the handling of successive central and state governments in the Maoist belts, Kashmir and the northeast demonstrates considerable public policy failure, and while even several educated people do get radicalized and identity-based and ideological fault-lines do need to be logically eradicated, access to public goods and services, like roads, education and health care (which even free market economists like Milton Friedman have held to be a responsibility of the government, at least to a certain extent), obviously remains an important part of the equation, though given the militancy in these particular regions, even this does become more challenging than elsewhere. Institutionalizing the access to these public goods and services as rights can go a long way in preventing neglect of some regions compared to others owing to low electoral representation, as is the case with the people of the northeast in the national context, and Jammuites and Ladakhis (cutting across religious lines) in the context of J&K or even the Darjeeling region inhabited by Gorkhas, Lepchas etc. in the context of West Bengal, for example. Given that the BJP is in power in coalition in J&K, it would do well to push for an RTE Act there for the children of Jammu, Kashmir and Ladakh, but one which ought to be free from the original drawbacks of the central statute.